Horror Movies: When it comes to public movie consumption, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences hasn’t always been the most “in touch” of organisations. After all, they did nominate Ryan Gosling for an Oscar for his role as Ken in Barbie, but they forgot to recognise director Great Gerwig and star Margot Robbie. a choice that went against everything the film aimed to advocate.
In addition to ignoring specific actors and directors, the Academy has a history of ignoring entire genres—horror films, for example—when choosing best picture. Yes, films like Get Out, The Sixth Sense, and The Exorcist have been nominated for Best Picture. However, the six films nominated for Best Picture barely scratch the surface of scary pictures that can be compared to any Best Picture winner in the awards’ history.
Just in the last five years, horror directors have created some genuinely beautiful pictures with outstanding performances and profound themes that are typically honoured by the Academy. Our goal is to give these five films the recognition they merit and demonstrate that they were fully deserving of a Best Picture nomination.
5 Recent Horror Movies That Should Have Earned a Best Picture Nomination
5. Last Night in Soho (2021)
When Ellie, a young girl experiencing mental health issues, moves to London to attend the London College of Fashion, she ends up in the vivid dreams of an aspirant singer who was murdered. Last Night in Soho, a writer and filmmaker, has been called Edgar Wright’s “dark valentine” love letter to London and, more precisely, the Soho district. In the movie, the setting is just as much of a character as the actual, living players. With a standout soundtrack and starring Anya Taylor-Joy, Diana Rigg, Thomasin McKenzie, and Matt Smith, Last Night in Soho could be considered Wright’s greatest work to date.
Last Night in Soho is a fantastic movie that deserves a best picture consideration in part because of the story that Wright and Krysty Wilson-Cairns, who is nominated for an Academy Award, wrote together. Co-writing the 1917 Best Picture nominee with Sam Mendes, Cairns drew inspiration for the story from her own experiences working as a barman in Soho. The two share a story about how, in spite of the utter darkness that frequently results from the past, society may romanticise it. When taken as a whole, the movie demonstrates a director at the pinnacle of his profession and is regarded as one of the greatest of 2021.
4.The Menu (2022)
The Menu, a series of films starring Anya Taylor-Joy, follows the tale of an eccentric chef and the people he plans to serve at a private dinner. As the evening goes on and the number of bodies rises, nothing is as it seems. In addition to Taylor-Joy, Mark Mylod—a director of only four feature films—also stars Ralph Fiennes, Janet McTeer, and Nicholas Hoult.
The performers in the movie and the twisted storyline enhance the perfect blend of humour and horror that is The Menu. The Menu would not appear at the Academy Awards at all, despite the fact that both Fiennes and Taylor-Joy would receive Golden Globe nods for the movie. The movie is comparable to Triangle of Sadness, another 2022 release that offers a bleak comedy and received a Best Picture nomination. Given that The Menu has garnered more critical and financial acclaim than its predecessor, it is puzzling that the Academy passed over this feature.
3. Bones and All (2022)
The bizarre love tale of two young cannibalistic lovers who are on the run across the nation is told in Bones and All. Luca Guadagnino’s original romantic comedy features a cast led by Taylor Russell and Timothée Chalamet. The film, which is based on the same-titled novel published in 2015, received great acclaim for its world premiere at the 79th Venice International Film Festival. In March 2022, it will open nationwide.
Luca Guadagnino, the director, has a history of producing a Best Picture nominee. In 2018, his film Call Me By Your Name, which also stars Chalamet, received numerous nominations. Although the film’s subject matter may have hindered its potential for greater success, particularly in the Academy’s eyes, Bones and All delves deeply into concepts of identity and locating oneself in the world. Although the horror movie received numerous independent award nominations, its rightful recognition ought to have permeated the Academy’s popular perception.
2. Pearl (2022)
In 2022, director Ti West was incredibly prolific, helming two of the most impressive horror movies of the previous ten years. Both X and Pearl exceeded the expectations of both horror enthusiasts and critics in 2022 and revolutionised what a successful horror picture could look like. While X would serve as the beginning of West’s trilogy, which ends with MaXXXine in 2024, Pearl is the film in which the director really excels. The film, which stars Mia Goth in the lead role, centres on Pearl and her ambitions to become an actor, as well as the guilt and suppression that prevent her from achieving her goals, no matter how impractical they may seem.
Martin Scorsese, the multiple Academy Award winner and nominee, called Pearl “mesmerising”. Although praise from a legendary director such as Martin Scorsese is highly significant, it is sadly insufficient to secure the picture a nomination for Best Picture. Even though Pearl is among the more blatantly “horror” films on this list, its narrative goes beyond this. Pearl is an excellent movie, but without the much-needed generational shift within the Academy, it might never receive the proper recognition it merits in the form of Hollywood’s “biggest honour.”
1.Talk to Me (2023)
The classic tale of a group of humans communicating with ghosts from beyond the grave and the potential repercussions is recounted in Talk to Me. The terrifying story of the Australian horror movie, which is directed by first-time directors Danny and Michael Philippou, is based on decades’ worth of horror movie storytelling. After making its premiere at the 2023 Sundance Film Festival, the movie went through a bidding war for distribution, which was eventually won by A24, the new home of avant-garde horror films. The movie will be distributed in theatres in the US in the summer of 2023.
Within a succinct ninety-five minutes, Talk to Me manages to convey a very emotional tale, replete with outstanding acting from its youthful and largely inexperienced ensemble. Tentpole films like Barbie and Oppenheimer, both of which were nominated for Best Picture, dominated 2023. The majority of general audiences don’t know about Talk to Me, but it hasn’t prevented the Academy in previous years. Voters might have viewed the producers and actors negatively because of their youthful vibe. Maybe there was just too much people in the field for a small engine that could communicate well with me.